Evaluate alternative actions

science sources, differing views (Thimk), info sources, alcohol, H5N1, public involvement Comments Off

2006-07-27 I moved this up from a comment on Local alcohol prohibition, police presence and serious injury in isolated Alaska Native villages so I could better characterize the entry. mpb

I have been assembling references about alcohol control points and whether increasing prohibition (which the City Council of Bethel wishes to do) has any effect on the rate (prevalence) or incidence of crime, chronic alcoholism, or addiction. The references have been assembled in

http://www.connotea.org/user/Hlthenvt

or use your own tags (search terms) to find similar articles cited in the collection as a whole

http://www.Connotea.org

This issue [further alcohol control through a city-run office] needs careful examination which the City of Bethel Council hasn’t yet done, before changing community policy.** Public involvement procedures should provide at least three proposed alternatives–

  • no action
  • action 1
  • action 2
  • with the pros and cons (positive and negative impacts) of each alternative. (Or, multiple working hypotheses with procedures to falsify them.)

    [**the proposal was removed from City Council action by a special election which now requires any establishment of a city-run alcohol dispensing center to be put to a vote of all Bethel voters.]


    Site Search Tags: , , , ,

    Local alcohol prohibition, police presence and serious injury in isolated Alaska Native villages

    demography, tribal governments, measures (scientific), alcohol 3 Comments »

    Reference Number: DSW2201, Year of Publication: 2006
    Authors: Gruenewald, Paul; Wood, Darryl
    Keywords: Alcohol Regulation, Injury, Native Americans

    Citation: Wood, D.S. and Gruenewald, P.J. “Local alcohol prohibition, police presence and serious injury in isolated Alaska Native villages,” Addiction, 101(3):393-403, March 2006.

    Abstract:

    Aims: To consider the effects of alcohol prohibition and police presence upon serious injury in isolated Alaska Native villages.

    Design: We compared rates of injury attributed to assault, self-harm, motor vehicle collisions and ‘other causes’ between villages with or without local prohibition and between villages with or without local police. Negative binomial regression was used to assess the relative effects of prohibition and police presence upon serious injury rates net of potential confounders.

    Read the rest of this entry »


    WordPress Theme & Icons by N.Design Studio. Hosted by edublogs - online education tools and community.
    Entries RSS Comments RSS Login